Title | Purpose | Brief description | Location |
Agcas (n.d.), Research. (Link) (Paid/Restricted) | U P C E | Agcas publish a programme of research on Higher Education careers issues and services. Some reports are publicly available but many are open only to membership. A review of themes covered by Agcas from 1977 to 2023 is provided here. | UK |
International Centre for Career Development and Public Policy (n.d.), Posts - by specific groups (Link) | P | The ICCDPP publish article and , research announcements into different segments, including Higher Education. | International |
Bimrose, J., Barnes, S.-A. and Brown, J. (2005). A Systematic Literature Review of Research into Career-Related Interventions for Higher Education.Manchester: Prospects. (Link) | C | The paper provides a literature review of evaluation studies into the effects of career guidance in higher education. The report showed that although there is substantial literature on different curricular and extra-curricular interventions, evidence related to their impact was limited. | International |
Allen, J. et al (2007). Research Centre for Education and the Labour Market Maastricht University, The Netherlands (Link)
| U E | The REFLEX project (acronym for ‘Research into Employment and professional FLEXibility’) was a large scale international project that has been carried by surveying 70k higher education students across a range of different countries (including the UK). It focuses on evaluating whether national education systems lead to graduates that have specific skills demands that the modern knowledge society places on higher education graduates to have, and the degree to which higher education equips graduates with the competencies to meet these demands. Such skills still appear pertinent today, with the uncertainties in the economy, the pace of change and the global perspective needed for many graduate roles.
| International |
Hansen, M., & Pedersen, J. (2012). An examination of the effects of career development courses on career decision-making self-efficacy, adjustment to college, learning integration, and academic success. Journal of the First-Year Experience & Students in Transition, 24(2), 33-61. (Link) (Paid) | P C | This study investigated the effects of career development courses on various aspects of a student's motivations and capabilities: Improvements were found across a number of outcomes including adjusting to a new college environment and retention rates. | US |
Bimrose, J., & Artess, J. (2007). Research into career-related interventions for higher education. What do we know and what do we need to know?. Journal of the National Institute for Career Education and Counselling, 17(1), 12-15. (Link) | C | The paper updates and discusses the results of the 2005 literature review by Bimrose et al. The review provides a milestone in evidencing careers research, talking of both evaluations that have been positive to date but limitations in the evidence base. | UK |
O'Reirden, D. (2017), Does careers education work? Measuring the impact of credit bearing careers education and considering the motivations of students for choosing such learning. HEA Annual Conference 2017 - Generation TEF: Teaching in the spotlight (Link) | P C | The results of a 10 module taught career learning programme were found from evaluation at the University of Dundee. The evaluation showed a strong shift in capabilities and confidence of those undertaking the modules e.g. scores out of 5 typically doubled for statements such as "knowledge of what a good application form should contain" and "understanding what happens at interview and how to turn it into my advantage." Employment outcomes were also assessed: If a student had taken a careers module, the odds of them reaching a positive destination were 21.9% higher than if they had not taken a careers module. | Scotland |
UPP Foundation (2017), Social Mobility and University Careers Services. Report by the Bridge Group for the UPP Foundation (Link)
|
| This report was written to investigate the role of careers services in closing socio-economic gaps. It was noted that, although participation in higher education had widened, it was a myth that mere entry to HE overcame existing disadvantages. This paper describes practitioner the strategies and initiatives that were being deployed at the time to address social mobility challenges. |
| England |
Langher, V., Nannini, V., & Caputo, A. (2018). What do university or graduate students need to make the cut? A meta-analysis on career intervention effectiveness. Journal of Educational, Cultural and Psychological Studies (ECPS Journal), (17), 21-43. (Link) | P C | A meta-analysis was conducted on studies published between 2000 and 2015 which complied with the following inclusion criteria: university or graduate students as target population, the evaluation of specific career-related interventions or programs, and an experimental or quasi experimental design. The selection procedure resulted in 9 eligible studies out of 823 examined articles. The results indicated, on average, a large effect whereby better outcomes were found from from socio-constructivist interventions compared to those based on social cognition theory and person-environment fit models. Benefits included reductions in career indecision more than increases of decision-making self-efficacy. Implications are discussed for practice.
| |
Anthology (2019), Career Services Could be the Most Valuable Part of a Modern Post-Secondary Education (Link) | C E | The article is a discussion and argument for career services in US colleges, drawing from labour data. It includes evidence for strong employment outcome differences of students that found employment had visited (67%) vs not visited (59%) their college career services. | US |
Clayton, K., Wessel, R. D., McAtee, J., & Knight, W. E. (2019). KEY careers: Increasing retention and graduation rates with career interventions. Journal of Career Development, 46(4), 425-439. (Link) (Paid) | C | This study showed how promoting participation in a career intervention program increased 1-year retention and 4-year graduation rates compared to nonparticipants at a singular institution. Archival data of 14,099 were used from 2011–2014. Impacts were investigated by demographic group, and results found independent of race. | US |
Jackson, D., & Tomlinson, M. (2019). Career values and proactive career behaviour among contemporary higher education students. Journal of Education and Work, 32(5), 449-464. (Link)
| U | Based on the idea that “career values prioritised by individuals determine their career decision-making, career choice, and career outcomes”, the paper describes a survey to measure them and analysis to relate to behaviour. Values can be intrinsic (e.g. interest, learning potential) or extrinsic (e.g. pay, prospects). The research in this paper was carried out on n=413 UK higher education students. Results suggested higher education studies tend towards exhibiting greater intrinsic values, such as purpose-seeking and making a societal contribution. Results also contradicted the finding that males are more extrinsically motivated. The survey helps to understand the motivations from careers of this group, and how this might lead to deficits in preparing for a career.
| UK Australia |
Ozlem, U. K. (2019). The effects of career interventions on university students’ levels of career decision-making self-efficacy: A meta-analytic review. Australian Journal of Career Development, 28(3), 223-233. (Link) | P C | The paper examines 20 studies that meet criteria of research quality, and have examined the effect of career services on self-efficacy. The results show strong, positive results. The importance of self-efficacy is also described for being a predictor of the career success of students.
| International |
CMI (2021), Work Ready Graduates: Building employability skills for a hybrid world (Link)
| C | This report, in the wake of COVD, covers research into the skills that employers would like to see from graduates, the new behaviours that characterise work in more digital workplaces, and the career management skills that graduates will need to navigate the labour market. This research showed that Many employers still believe that graduates lack the ‘basic’ work-ready competencies that make up employability skills, there continues to be a skills gap, graduates from all disciplines need career management skills (not just business).
| UK |
Reardon, R. C., Peace, C. S., & Burbrink, I. E. (2021). College career courses and instructional research from 1976 through 2019. Scholarship of teaching and learning in psychology. (Link) | P C | This article examines 208 published articles from over 45 years about the development and effectiveness of career development courses in college / higher education settings, with special attention to those appearing in the five years before publication. The research found 93% of studies gave positive outcomes for positive psychological changes and 95% positive for outcomes such as graduation rates. Although the study’s interest is focussed on the psychology discipline, the analysis and learnings are largely transferable. | International US |
Agcas and Symplicity (2022), The opportunities and challenges of student engagement in careers and employability provision (Link)
| P E | Symplicy and Agas collaborated to carry out a study to understand barriers to student engagement with services. Symplicity found that technology and process improvement could yield “a 75% increase in student engagement through automation and simplification of process from appointment bookings and reporting, helping students navigate a blend of in-person and online support and resources. This report provides research findings from students and practitioners that includes the most and least engaged-with and valuable aspects of service, and the main challenges faced by career professionals. The report culminates in recommendations that include developing resources for micro-engagements, increased resourcing and engagement strategies. | England |
Cheng, M., Adekola, O., Albia, J. and Cai, S. (2022), "Employability in higher education: a review of key stakeholders' perspectives", Higher Education Evaluation and Development, Vol. 16 No. 1, pp. 16-31. (Link)
| C | This paper provides a two stage literature review to examine the concept of “employability” relating to Higher Education. It describes problems with the government’s decision to delegate responsibility to higher education. A gap is reported to exist between employers' expectation for employability and the government's employability agenda. The prognosis is provided that higher education will continue to be vocation driven, rather than for knowledge creation, should it continue to target solely employment outcomes.
| UK |
Freeman, J. and Hillman, N. (2022), How can you help me?: Students’ perspectives on careers services and employment. Higher Education Policy Institute. (Link) | C | The research polled 1,105 students online through the National Union of Students (NUS) to enquire about their experiences with careers services and their perspectives on graduate employment. Results showed student expectations and satisfaction with services received. For instance, in terms of expectations, students are split on whether or not they regard it as the responsibility of their higher education institution to find them a job, with one-third (34%) believing it is and only a slightly lower proportion (30%) saying it is not. A majority of students (53%) think ‘all university courses should be designed mainly with future employment in mind’. About half (49%) of polled students had used their career services. | UK |
Soares, J., Carvalho, C., & Silva, A. D. (2022). A systematic review on career interventions for university students: Framework, effectiveness, and outcomes. Australian Journal of Career Development, 31(2), 81-92. (Link)
| P C E | This study represents a large-scale literature review of guidance initiatives into Higher Education, covering 596 articles which were filtered down into 26 studies that met a criteria. These studies are cited and summarised. Analysis provided themes for the focus of the studies based on four question: (Q1) “What are the theoretical frameworks behind university students’ career interventions?”; (Q2) “What is the structure of these interventions?”; (Q3) “How the quality of these interventions have been evaluated?”; and (Q4) “What outcomes have been produced?”
| International |
VanDerziel, S. (2022). The value of career services. National Association of Colleges and Employers. (Link) | C | The article reviews work by the National Association of Colleges and Employers in the US that shows that career services has a quantifiable effect on students and their entry into the world of work: "Overall, analysis of results from our Class of 2022 Student Survey found an astounding correlation between career services and use of those services by graduating seniors: Graduating seniors who used at least one service—any service—received an average of 1.24 job offers. And, for every additional service they used beyond just one, their average number of job offers increased 0.05." | US |
Kozhuk, D. (2023), Why Higher Ed Should Invest in Career Services, Not Abolish It. Go U Connect (Link) | P C | The article is from the US and describes the case for career services to defend against challenges that they may be pared back. The article also includes several international examples of innovative career services that are argued to show the “outsized impact” that they can have on attracting students. | US |
Roberts, S., Lyall, B., Trott, V., Foeken, E., Smith, J., Robards, B., ... & Wright, B. (2023). Young Australians Navigating the ‘Careers Information Ecology’. Youth, 3(1), 300-320. (Link) | U | The paper explores young Australians’ (aged 15–24) career behaviour and particularly the navigation of careers information through a nationally representative survey (n = 1103), focus groups with 90 participants and an analysis of 15,227 social media comments. The authors suggest that the variety of formal and informal sources pursued and accessed by young people forms a relational ‘ecology’. This relationality is twofold. First, information is often sequential, and engagements with one source can inform the experience or pursuit of another. Second, navigation of the ecology is marked by a high level of intersubjectivity through interpersonal support networks including peers, family and formal service provision. The authors discuss the challenges this research presents to classic views of how young people go about career choices, with particular issues noted for disadvantaged groups. | Australia |
Nie, Z., & Zarei, H. (2023). A cross-cultural study on the career counseling service ecosystem: implications for higher education marketing. Journal of Marketing for Higher Education, 1–27. (Link) | P E | The motivation for the study is that “the body of knowledge in the higher education domain is scant on how a career service is created and delivered to suit the needs of students and the wider society.” The authors review practices for service creation in three nations: UK, Italy, and China. “The role of the career service is transitioning from a mere job placement service to a strategic and administrative function, which interacts with and influences various actors in the higher education ecosystem.” | UK Italy China |
Robertson, C., & Abkhezr, P. (2023). Reconstructing Stories of Career Adaptability Through the Integrative Structured Interview for Undergraduate University Students. Journal of Career Assessment. (Link) | P | Citing the importance of career adaptability, the authors develop and evaluate the use of a narrative career guidance interview that allows higher education students to “tell and connect with their stories of career adaptability”. Benefits for the career clients are described. | Australia |
Universities UK (2023) (Link) | E | The articles review recent data that shows universities are increasing graduate employment outcomes for their students. Interviews with successful universities cite “whole university” approaches to achieving their results, which have transformed career services. | UK |
Agcas (2024), Social mobility. Phoenix, the Agcas journal (Link) | P C | The report covers case studies of career service initiatives through the UK to address social mobility challenges | UK |
Mate, S., Gregory, K., & Ryan, J. (2024). Re-authoring career narratives: exploring identity in contemporary careers practice. British Journal of Guidance & Counselling, 52(1), 7-18. (Link) | P | The authors describe the “narrative career therapy” approach to careers counselling, in a study on higher education student clients. The process is outlined and benefits are found for helping students understand and develop identity. | Australia |
Prospects Luminate (2024), Early careers survey (Link)
| U P C | The survey measured responses from over 6,000 young people - from secondary school age to early adulthood - on their career plans and the sources of support that they received. Results were unfortunately not all split out by different career stages. However, for higher education students, the most useful sorts of guidance were considered to be: 1) Talks by staff about courses, 2) Career events, and 3) Help with applications and CVs. The survey also showed that work experiences could not be found by 40% of students, and it highlighted the broad goals. Financial concerns provided a prominent theme across the survey.
| UK |